Gender Balance at the Top Requires Career Planning, Not Quota (2020)

Paul Vanderbroeck

Career planning for creating gender balance at the top


Sometimes tried and tested HR practices have their use. One of those is career planning, which has its particular value for creating gender balance at the top. Regretfully, organisations opt for easy unsophisticated practices like quota to fill their leadership ranks with enough women. The result is the glass wall, i.e. women being concentrated in staff jobs as opposed to operational roles with profit and loss responsibility. Recent research by the Wall Street Journal as well as McKinsey’s annual Women in the Workplace reports attests to this point.


Career planning on the other hand is a sophisticated practice of developing talented individuals at the top by means of carefully selected job placements. Such assignments provide challenge and learning opportunities and particularly ensure that the individuals have the experiences they need to lead a company: functional, P&L and cross-border. Career planning works when it is based on methodical, psychodynamic assessment to identify strengths and development needs. And when the assignments are accompanied by learning accelerators such as executive coaching.  Through career planning, organisations are able to prepare the right successors for the top, as well as leveraging the entire talent pool.


What is your experience of career planning to increase gender balance?

KDVI Writer's Colony, 2020

Add Comment

Go back

Related content

One key obstacle for women to be identified and selected for senior roles is "leadership cloning”

Too feminine or not feminine enough? How to leverage your difference as a woman leader

Authenticity - which comes down to leveraging difference - is the key to career success as a woman leader. But women often find themselves in a double-bind - needing to fit the prevailing leadership prototype in order to be successful while at the same time needing to stay authentic. How do you get out of this double bind? Wait for organisations to change their leadership development and come up with a truly gender-neutral system? This is likely to make you miss the boat. The solution is rather in finding a way to become successful in the existing system. This blog explains how a psychodynamic approach to leadership development can help female leaders to be authentic.

Published on 7 Feb, 2018

Coaching female leaders with narcissistic tendencies

Coaching the Narcissistic Woman Leader

Following on from his first blog, 'Can a Woman Leader be a Narcissist', Paul's second blog explores specific approaches towards coaching female leaders with narcissistic tendencies. The blog provides insights for Executive and Leadership Development Professionals to customise leadership development to the individual strengths and weaknesses of women in the talent pool. 

Published on 15 Aug, 2018

Partner, Powerful. New Role Models for Women Leaders in 2021

Partner, Powerful. New Role Models for Women Leaders in 2021

Recent developments have given rise to examples where women are provided with more choice of what type of leader they can be. In this blog, Paul Vanderbroeck, suggests three alternative role models, giving hope for gender balance in leadership in the near future.

Published on 13 Jan, 2021

What successful women do to withhold them from growing further –  And what they should do instead

What successful women do to withhold them from growing further – And what they should do instead

What is next? How do I realise my future ambitions? Annette explores practical steps women can take to grow further in leadership.

"Let's talk about sex in the boardroom"

The Sexual “Cloud” in the Executive Suite

Manfred Kets de Vries explores whether sex and man’s unconscious drive for survival are keeping women locked out of the C-suite.

Published on 13 May, 2015

Leadership in the Next Phase of COVID-19

Leadership in the Next Phase of COVID-19

Around the world, plans are being launched to fight COVID-19. Impressive change management and leadership will be necessary to convince people to adjust their behaviour, to eventually conquer the virus and revive the economy.

Published on 15 Apr, 2020

"Sexual dynamics in the boardroom"

The Sexual “Cloud” in the Executive Suite

This working paper explores how people today are very much governed by the same sexual desires that drove our primitive ancestors.

Published on 13 May, 2015

Don’t wait for the world to change. Find your own individual way

For ambitious women leaders the path to success is individual: Change, navigate and leverage the context

Don’t wait for the world to change or for some quota to propel you to the top. Find your own individual way. But what does that mean?

Published on 9 Mar, 2020

“Think narcissist, think female!”

Can a woman leader be a narcissist?

"Think narcissist, think male"? A further addition to our narcissism blog series, this blog shows that women leaders, too, can be narcissistic. Yet it's a different kind of narcissism with different implications for leadership development. Three types of narcissistic women leaders - the Super Woman, the Perfectionist and the Lenient Leader - are examined.

Published on 23 Jul, 2018

#BeBold ForChange

International Women's Day

As International Women's Day is celebrated today across the globe, we asked ourselves what we would pledge to drive ground-breaking action within organisations to truly drive the greatest change for women.

Published on 7 Mar, 2017