Beware of the cultish techniques that have crossed into the workplace
Why would anyone be attracted to a cult? Most quiver at the thought of the Manson family, the Heaven’s Gate millenarian cult or the Jonestown cult, whose fanaticism led to either murder or mass suicide. Of course, cults can also take somewhat more innocuous forms such as the Hare Krishnas, New Age groups or even cults of personality or gurus.
More broadly, a cult is defined as “great devotion to a person, idea, object, movement, or work”. As such, political groupings, lifestyle groups, criminal associations and even political regimes may also be considered forms of cults. Many businesses have cult-like characteristics as well. These include influential leaders who inspire devotion and demand loyalty; an inward-looking corporate culture; stringent rules regarding behaviour; and intolerance of deviation from the established norms.
At the most fundamental level, cults fulfil our human search for meaning. They offer clear and absolute answers to difficult questions such as the meaning of life, good vs. evil, religious matters, politics, etc. In addition, cults feed our need for structure and order. Some people join cults simply out of loneliness and a desire to be part of something bigger than themselves.
Unsurprisingly, many cult leaders radiate charisma, seducing devotees with a siren song. Cult leaders know how to speak to these basic desires. Masters of mind control, they excel at making new recruits feel loved and important, telling them exactly what they like to hear. But behind this veneer of charm, many cult leaders possess anti-social and even psychopathic personality traits.
The psychodynamics of cults
Complex psychological dynamics are at play in the creation of a cult. Cult leaders are often bestowed with “magical powers”, parallel to children’s early perceptions of their parents as omnipresent and in control of their universe. In a similar vein, members of a cult regress and defer to their leaders to shape their thoughts and world view. This enables cult leaders to propagate lies and distortions to the point where their followers can no longer distinguish between what’s real and what’s imagined.
To maintain absolute control, cult leaders encourage their followers to sever ties with the outside world. An effective technique to isolate cult members is to propagate paranoid thinking through an “us vs. them” mentality – where “them” are families or even the government portrayed as a villain, and “us” is the cult as a safe harbour. Cut off from their former connections, converts become even more dependent on the cult to meet their physical and emotional needs.
Despite all of this, cult members are often unaware of their situation and remain under the impression that they are acting on their own initiative. Although the contrary is obvious to outsiders, followers may have little idea of what has happened to them. The walls of their self-imposed prison are invisible.
As mentioned earlier, many social and corporate entities possess cult-like characteristics. Although less intrusive compared to religious cults, these entities also engage in similar forms of the conversion process. For example, many business organisations propagate commanding ideologies and cultural values. While providing their employees with a sense of meaning, purpose and belonging, they also require a strict adherence to a set of beliefs. Dissenters are swiftly punished.
Some of these organisations have charismatic leaders with whom employees can easily identify. The rank and file can be tempted to look up to these leaders as models of how they should act, think and feel. Due to the nature of their socialisation processes, employees can become so emotionally bound to their firm that work soon becomes more important than family and community.
Just like in bona fide cults, organisations can breed paranoid thinking. Corporate identity is often drawn in opposition to hostile outside forces, making “us vs. them” behaviour the norm. These cult-like organisations are not known for encouraging creative thinking. Dogma and mind control stifle the sharing of ideas, opinions and constructive criticism.
We should all be on guard for cult-like organisations. To resist the siren call, we need to be vigilant. We need to reject black-and-white thinking and seek every opportunity to engage in healthy debate. When problems crop up, discern the objective issues at hand, examine all angles and raise above scapegoating.
Lastly, let’s appreciate those thoughtful leaders who encourage critical thinking, prize sound judgment, value individuality and radiate authenticity. After all, the acid test of good leadership is the ability to unlock the potential of followers to make them better, not enslave them.
This article is republished courtesy of INSEAD Knowledge.
Copyright INSEAD 2018
INSEAD Knowledge, 2018Read more
"Corporate genius and psychopaths"
This blog entry with the Harvard Business Review. discusses the thin line between corporate genius and psychopaths.
Published on 7 Jan, 2014
Inscribe courageous conversations into organisational DNA
How to create an organisation where people find meaning in, and are captivated by, their work.
Published on 21 Jun, 2019
"Creating healthy work places for the new millennium"
This article raises questions about the well-functioning individual, the motivational need systems that drive people, and the conditions that make for healthy organisations.
Published on 1 Jan, 2001
In this book the processes of individual and organizational change their characteristics and dynamics are explored, and resemblances between personal and organizational change are highlighted.
Published on 30 Nov, 1996
"Creating authentizotic organisations"
This article is a rejoinder to the critique by Robert Golembiewski of the authors' article Transforming the Mind-Set of the Organization: A Clinical Perspective, in which the processes of individual and organizational change and the resemblance between them are explored.
Published on 1 Jan, 1999
"A look at Russian history and capitalism"
This article reflects on the history of Russia, focusing on the country's late-20th and early-21st-century development as the Russian Federation.
Published on 1 Jul, 2008
"Unraveling the processes of change"
In this paper, the processes of individual and organisational change—their characteristics and dynamics—are explored, and resemblances between personal and organizational change are highlighted.
Published on 1 Jan, 1999
“Why am I frantically pursuing wealth?”
Greed is less about accumulating wealth than filling an inner void.
Published on 6 Sep, 2019
This paper discusses the internal and external pressures that may trigger organisational changes and explores the four stages of the organisational change process.
Published on 6 Feb, 2009
"M&As: The untold story"
This blog looks at the very human factors are at play in mergers and acquisitions. Paying attention to them can increase ones chance of success.
Published on 2 Feb, 2016